Sara é uma romancista que não encontra inspiração quando conhece Godfrey, um homem estranho e azarado que muda constantemente de personagem e alter ego para lidar com seu passado e evitar a realidade.

Maggie is facing Christmas alone until Lucas become an unexpected house guest.

Jessica gets dumped before Christmas. She sends 5 Christmas cards, affecting her BFF, brother, aunt, pop star, and past music/cello teacher, meeting her single, photographer son.

Kent devises a revenge plan against Laurel, whose husband he believed ruined his marriage, however, his plan becomes deadly once Laurel decides to fight back.